933 replies to this topic

[BlitzPlayer]

Just because we are random.



Funny thing is we had a debate on whether we should go for Cloud instead. Good thing we didn't lol.

[Mister Mischief]

I don't mind losing, but don't try blaming this on me by changing plum up.

I know the cop should try and keep a low profile, but if you look at the past games I've played, that's not my style, and playing any differently would wreck me in the eyes of the others.

I wasn't on and didn't have time to go back over things, but if you look I was already starting to call bullplum on that Tikal/Agel chao thing...I mean angel chao...really? Next time claim a more legitimate character, and be quicker about telling us the "power" you gain, because I was inspecting skuff tonight.

You didn't give me credit for getting the town to vote for BP, instead giving it to Skuff.

You say today was my fault? Most of the people voted, so I obviously gave plenty of notice, unfortunately, they didn't listen to me when I give them someone who is 100% mafia and I was clearly the cop. Even if I had revealed my inspection results sooner, I wouldn't have been on after that, and Skuff/Dz could have still pulled the same thing. So how would have posting sooner have changed anything?

Oh, and lets not forget the "None of the townies believed Formless was Vector", when I posted more than once I fully believed him.

Nice game, you ran it well, the roles were cool and well thought out, everything was decently balanaced. Commentary at the end was more opinion than actual summary, but then maybe you just missed some of my posts...

Edited by Mister Mischief, 01 August 2009 - 05:10 PM.

[drew]

Awesome game jib, roles were great.

Thanks for the mvp choice, I'm quite proud lol. Yeah, I told you guys psi was skummy... I was wrong in why he was, but still not a hard peg that he was mafia.

[Tenken]

There was no reason for the mafia to kill me =\. I guess they thought I was lieing. What is the the point of a townie silencer.

Also, while it is bad for some people, role claiming is a very easy way to pinpoint mafia. If one of the masons claimed, that would be 3 confirmed townies, until one died. There is the chance that mafia lies a role, but then they have to hope it isn't in the game/the player is inactive. Usually lame guys won't be in the game, so they would get more FoS later.
A complaint is role claiming takes away from the strategy.

Also, my role said I came here with Silver. Flavor text or not, I wanted to see.

[Cloud954]

Man I rule. It's ok Mafia, I'm glad I could help you guys out. I just thought it was funny I got really lucky with the two kills a night two nights in a row. I mean, it was like I started with the 7 emeralds already. Also, sorry for targeting you so much wit, haha. Really, I went for the people I thought would be most likely to figure me out, which was you and Savior. It was just luck that the other two got in the way both times. Also, I didn't know for sure you were Sonic; I figured you wouldn't be since you had claimed Sonic in the other game, so it's not like I purposely had a deathwish. grapeing Amy, man. No way she would've been able to single-handedly kill Chaos.

[JiB]

[quote name='Mister Mischief' date='01 August 2009 - 09:07 PM' timestamp='1249175235' post='1337658']
I don't mind losing, but don't try blaming this on me by changing plum up.

I know the cop should try and keep a low profile, but if you look at the past games I've played, that's not my style, and playing any differently would wreck me in the eyes of the others.

I wasn't on and didn't have time to go back over things, but if you look I was already starting to call bullplum on that Tikal/Agel chao thing...I mean angel chao...really? Next time claim a more legitimate character, and be quicker about telling us the "power" you gain, because I was inspecting skuff tonight.

You didn't give me credit for getting the town to vote for BP, instead giving it to Skuff.

You say today was my fault? Most of the people voted, so I obviously gave plenty of notice, unfortunately, they didn't listen to me when I give them someone who is 100% mafia and I was clearly the cop. Even if I had revealed my inspection results sooner, I wouldn't have been on after that, and Skuff/Dz could have still pulled the same thing. So how would have posting sooner have changed anything?

Oh, and lets not forget the "None of the townies believed Formless was Vector", when I posted more than once I fully believed him.

Nice game, you ran it well, the roles were cool and well thought out, everything was decently balanaced. Commentary at the end was more opinion than actual summary, but then maybe you just missed some of my posts...
[/quote]


my only complaint is your 'wanting to get more info' when all the info was there for you already.

master pretty much had the game figured out. savior had it figured out and he was dead.

even so, you were definitely the 2nd person in contention for the mvp, you played your role well, other than the fact that i didnt like how you 'waited' after you found someone.

Edited by JiB, 01 August 2009 - 10:36 PM.

[Psi]

I wanted to either negate MM, kill Master or negate Master, kill MM Night 3 but I was gone that entire night and couldn't tell the mafia. I think I was the only one that realized Master was the doctor, because they were about to lynch Ryan Day 4 before I told them not to.

I don't understand how I slipped late in the game. Day 4 I picked a power that Chip might actually have, stealing emeralds. All the townies still believed I was mafia. Night 4 I challenged MM to inspect me, which is what I was going for, because I didn't want him to inspect Skuff or DZDX like he should have. It turns out Drew wanted to track me again, and there was nothing I could obviously do about that. If questioned I would have said "I didn't want to risk picking the target the mafia killed knowing that you were going to track me," but Drew actually said that himself.

I'm glad I wasn't day lynched. I have still yet to be day lynched in a mafia game (Yay!)

[BlitzPlayer]

Tenken, you are the day 2 master. Proven fact.




We had to kill you. lol

[JiB]

[quote name='Psi' date='02 August 2009 - 03:12 AM' timestamp='1249197135' post='1337860']
I wanted to either negate MM, kill Master or negate Master, kill MM Night 3 but I was gone that entire night and couldn't tell the mafia. I think I was the only one that realized Master was the doctor, because they were about to lynch Ryan Day 4 before I told them not to.

I don't understand how I slipped late in the game. Day 4 I picked a power that Chip might actually have, stealing emeralds. All the townies still believed I was mafia. Night 4 I challenged MM to inspect me, which is what I was going for, because I didn't want him to inspect Skuff or DZDX like he should have. It turns out Drew wanted to track me again, and there was nothing I could obviously do about that. If questioned I would have said "I didn't want to risk picking the target the mafia killed knowing that you were going to track me," but Drew actually said that himself.

I'm glad I wasn't day lynched. I have still yet to be day lynched in a mafia game (Yay!)
[/quote]


lol be more active i would have gave you mvp then for the whole game if u would have pulled the 'negate master kill mm' on night 3.

[drew]

Random question: I'm assuming BP sent PSI to send in the kill the first night I chose to follow him? Then sent someone else the 2nd night? Or was the first night purely lucky? (Or unlucky lol)

[JiB]

no, he used his normal power on blitz before he died. :/

[Psi]

I was never sent to kill anyone

[drew]

[quote name='Psi' date='02 August 2009 - 09:10 AM' timestamp='1249222258' post='1338059']
I was never sent to kill anyone
[/quote]
Haha wow. You were still painfully skummy though, honestly.

[Psi]

I almost got the town to lynch the cop day 2, but day 4 I admit I was pretty sloppy because I was upset you guys were going to lynch me for the wrong reason.