517 replies to this topic

[Toxic`]

win. good job skuff.

[Skuff]

[quote]I said I was going to trust Skuff because I didn't want to die, and as a final test. If Skuff was the SK I'd live, if Jib was the SK, I was deffinitaly dead. [/quote]

This makes sense to me
Me as a townie was pretty straightforward the entire game
but the kill decisions i made as the sk not only reflected on me, but everyone who was being suspected for most of the sk hunt
i did some some comfort as a townie when you said you trusted me, but i guess besides fitting in the rest of you, my main motive as a townie was to get you guys to lynch the wrong person. looking back, wit was a dumb choice, and killing mm, the person who said he trusted me somewhat in public, would have made more sense. final three: me, jib, wit. jib votes for me, i vote for jib, wit votes for, i don't even know who wit would have voted for, probably me though. i didn't really think i would win but i knew that if i did, i would rule so grapeing hard
i don't regret voting for jib right off the bat today, i would have done that if i was a townie who trusted mm and thought jib was the sk.
i do regret some stuff like, sending in my kill when jib was offline
i thought expecting mm to vote jib after that was kind of a long shot
oh well

Edited by Skuff, 02 November 2009 - 12:36 PM.

[Mister Mischief]

Since people seem curious about the logic that lead me to vote Skuff instead of Jib, I'll share it.
[quote name='Achilles' date='02 November 2009 - 03:45 AM' timestamp='1257155122' post='1427972']
I'm not sure how you figured it out, but [b]sick[/b] calls nonetheless. Skuff is indeed the [b]serial killer.[/b] Town wins!
[/quote]
My "clues"/logic in order from the most important to the least:

[list]
[*]Skuff voting for Drew instead of Jib.
[*]The night kill where Wit posted the times we were active, and only Skuff and myself were on during that time period to send in said kill. Although it was possible Jib sent in the kill in advance, this was still a good clue.
[*] Skuff's play style was similar to how I've seen him play as scum in a previous game.
[*]Wit being killed instead of me.
[*]Jib really wasn't on for long stretches of time, and his rage over some issues seemed sincere.
[*]Jib seemed super scummy, which didn't fit his play style as scum at all.
[*]There was some other small slips from Skuff, but I'm not going over them for him to use against me later next time he's scum.
[*]A theory I had that people who got role PMs were more likely to be among those who confirmed early.
[*]I thought as soon as Skuff was inspected and showed up townie how funny it would be if he was the SK, and wanted to lynch him this whole time just to make sure he wasn't.
[/list]

[Cloud954]

Skuff should still win a medal.

[JiB]

*Jib seemed super scummy, which didn't fit his play style as scum at all.


that is a HUGE catch.

A lot of people dont realize that Scum try extra hard NOT to be scummy. Townies dont have anything to lose, so they dont doublecheck all their posts before posting, therefore, things can come out that can portray them as 'scum'.

[Skuff]

[*]Skuff voting for Drew instead of Jib.

I can't really be held to something like this as a SK slip because the entire time I was pretending to be a townie, I was playing just like I do when I really am a townie, and that includes the votes that i make. "Townies have nothing to lose" - yeah they do, if they say something dumb that gets them mislynched, the game being messed up is kind of their fault. do you guys remember when kaiser gogeta played? yeah. i kinda doublecheck my posts when i'm a townie, but i thought i was doing ok at not seeming too uptight about anything

[*]The night kill where Wit posted the times we were active, and only Skuff and myself were on during that time period to send in said kill. Although it was possible Jib sent in the kill in advance, this was still a good clue.

more like a slip

[*] Skuff's play style was similar to how I've seen him play as scum in a previous game.

which games are you thinking of, out of curiosity, because that dumb chart i made and almost didn't even post wasn't like a well thought out move that i wanted to declare my innocence

[*]Wit being killed instead of me.

perhaps. i was going to kill you really early in the game but i changed my mind about it twice, not sure if me changing my mind made me last longer than i would have if i didn't, or if it cost me the game. like i already said though, wit maybe wasn't the best choice, maybe i was hoping too hard for you to lean a little bit more towards jib than me

[*]There was some other small slips from Skuff, but I'm not going over them for him to use against me later next time he's scum.

raspberry yeah right

[*]A theory I had that people who got role PMs were more likely to be among those who confirmed early.

my role pm was in my inbox after i got off of a suspension, so no

[*]I thought as soon as Skuff was inspected and showed up townie how funny it would be if he was the SK, and wanted to lynch him this whole time just to make sure he wasn't.

that's funny; i killed fresh because i was hoping he wasn't mafia. fresh and bp? oooh, scary
that was the kill that ended up negating fresh's toxic kill >:

[Mister Mischief]

[quote name='Skuff' date='02 November 2009 - 05:31 PM' timestamp='1257204687' post='1428445']
[*]Skuff voting for Drew instead of Jib.

I can't really be held to something like this as a SK slip because the entire time I was pretending to be a townie, I was playing just like I do when I really am a townie, and that includes the votes that i make. "Townies have nothing to lose" - yeah they do, if they say something dumb that gets them mislynched, the game being messed up is kind of their fault. do you guys remember when kaiser gogeta played? yeah. i kinda doublecheck my posts when i'm a townie, but i thought i was doing ok at not seeming too uptight about anything

[*]The night kill where Wit posted the times we were active, and only Skuff and myself were on during that time period to send in said kill. Although it was possible Jib sent in the kill in advance, this was still a good clue.

more like a slip

[*] Skuff's play style was similar to how I've seen him play as scum in a previous game.

which games are you thinking of, out of curiosity, because that dumb chart i made and almost didn't even post wasn't like a well thought out move that i wanted to declare my innocence

[*]Wit being killed instead of me.

perhaps. i was going to kill you really early in the game but i changed my mind about it twice, not sure if me changing my mind made me last longer than i would have if i didn't, or if it cost me the game. like i already said though, wit maybe wasn't the best choice, maybe i was hoping too hard for you to lean a little bit more towards jib than me

[*]There was some other small slips from Skuff, but I'm not going over them for him to use against me later next time he's scum.

raspberry yeah right

[*]A theory I had that people who got role PMs were more likely to be among those who confirmed early.

my role pm was in my inbox after i got off of a suspension, so no

[*]I thought as soon as Skuff was inspected and showed up townie how funny it would be if he was the SK, and wanted to lynch him this whole time just to make sure he wasn't.

that's funny; i killed fresh because i was hoping he wasn't mafia. fresh and bp? oooh, scary
that was the kill that ended up negating fresh's toxic kill >:
[/quote]
You voting Drew is obviously a big thing when Jib was the better move for the town since everyone suspected him.
I've told you before, I'm not sure which game, but I know I'm right.
There really were other small slips, I think I mentioned some of them during the game, you can go back and look if you want.
There's a reason the "theory" was low down on the list, but it proved accurate, and your suspension doesn't make it invalid.
IDG what Fresh and BP have to do with anything I was saying, but it was obvious Fresh was mafia.

[Skuff]

everyone suspected drew too, if i recall the moment where i said i'd tie break if it was tied between jib and drew. all i was saying is that if i was a townie i would have done the same thing

[Fresh]

Good job guys.

[drew]

I was only ever suspected at all because I made a move that nobody else wanted to do, and made a vote. If you look back, jib tops most everyone's list, while I'm down around the bottom of lists. Therefore I still dont really understand how I became suspected lol

[JiB]

i dont understand how i was suspected in the first place.

[Fresh]

I had a whole plan set up. =/

[drew]

[quote name='Fresh' date='03 November 2009 - 01:54 PM' timestamp='1257278057' post='1429353']
I had a whole plan set up. =/
[/quote]
do tell.

[Skuff]

grape your plan i raped you

[Fresh]

I can see that.

[Skuff]

niiiiiiigger please

[Fresh]

Start you game already.

[Skuff]

i'll start it in an hour or two
it will start in night 1