Help
Sign In »
Register Now!
Can I use Dark Illusion to negate my opponent's Solemn Judgment when he/she attempts to Tribute Summon his/her Jinzo?
Welcome to ETC Forums!
|
Welcome to ETC Forums!
We are a friendly online community for Yugioh, providing information, spoilers, articles, decks, and many other things. What sets us apart from other boards is that our community actually likes to get to know people, and we want you to be a part of it. We hold lots of contests exclusively for our members, and we always give away booster packs and tins as prizes. I hope your visit today shows you what a great community we have, so join today! |
|
| Guest Message by DevFuse | |
Page 1 of 1
Dark Illusion vs Solemn Judgment
#2
Posted 07 November 2009 - 05:25 PM
So from your example this is what I'm seeing.
Player A has a face down Dark Bribe that has been set for at least one turn and has one or more monsters that can be used for a tribute summon. Player B has a face down Solemn Judgement.
Player A sacrifices a monster in order to summon Jinzo.
Player B responds with a Solmen Judgment trying to negate Jinzo's tribute summon.
"Solemn Judgement" does not "target" the card it is trying to negate and destroy so no "Dark Illusion" can not be chained to a Solemn Judgement trying to negate and destroy a Jinzo, or any other dark monster for that matter.
Player A has a face down Dark Bribe that has been set for at least one turn and has one or more monsters that can be used for a tribute summon. Player B has a face down Solemn Judgement.
Player A sacrifices a monster in order to summon Jinzo.
Player B responds with a Solmen Judgment trying to negate Jinzo's tribute summon.
"Solemn Judgement" does not "target" the card it is trying to negate and destroy so no "Dark Illusion" can not be chained to a Solemn Judgement trying to negate and destroy a Jinzo, or any other dark monster for that matter.
This post has been edited by Xerodynamicz: 07 November 2009 - 05:26 PM
#3
- Fly or Die
-
- Posts: 10603
- Joined: 29-November 06
- DN:Krizzmatik
- Gender: Male
- Location: Buffalo, New York
- Feedback: View
Posted 07 November 2009 - 05:41 PM
Xerodynamicz, on 07 November 2009 - 05:25 PM, said:
So from your example this is what I'm seeing.
Player A has a face down Dark Bribe that has been set for at least one turn and has one or more monsters that can be used for a tribute summon. Player B has a face down Solemn Judgement.
Player A sacrifices a monster in order to summon Jinzo.
Player B responds with a Solmen Judgment trying to negate Jinzo's tribute summon.
"Solemn Judgement" does not "target" the card it is trying to negate and destroy so no "Dark Illusion" can not be chained to a Solemn Judgement trying to negate and destroy a Jinzo, or any other dark monster for that matter.
Player A has a face down Dark Bribe that has been set for at least one turn and has one or more monsters that can be used for a tribute summon. Player B has a face down Solemn Judgement.
Player A sacrifices a monster in order to summon Jinzo.
Player B responds with a Solmen Judgment trying to negate Jinzo's tribute summon.
"Solemn Judgement" does not "target" the card it is trying to negate and destroy so no "Dark Illusion" can not be chained to a Solemn Judgement trying to negate and destroy a Jinzo, or any other dark monster for that matter.
Also note that Solemn Judgment doesn't destroy the monster. It negates it's summon.
Voted YugiohETCForums.com's Most Charismatic Poster (2010)
Voted YugiohETCForums.com's Most Charismatic Poster (2011)
#4
Posted 07 November 2009 - 05:48 PM
Cept that Solemn Judgment negates the summon & then destroys the monster while its considered to be in the player's hand. Unless this question is actually about Forced Back, which doesn't target either.
work by Johnny :)
Trade List / Refs
Mavs, on 28 January 2011 - 04:39 PM, said:
Don't hate on the bitches.
#5
- Fly or Die
-
- Posts: 10603
- Joined: 29-November 06
- DN:Krizzmatik
- Gender: Male
- Location: Buffalo, New York
- Feedback: View
Posted 07 November 2009 - 05:51 PM
Val, on 07 November 2009 - 05:48 PM, said:
Cept that Solemn Judgment negates the summon & then destroys the monster while its considered to be in the player's hand. Unless this question is actually about Forced Back, which doesn't target either.
I forgot that bit. Thanks Val.
Voted YugiohETCForums.com's Most Charismatic Poster (2010)
Voted YugiohETCForums.com's Most Charismatic Poster (2011)
Share this topic:
Page 1 of 1
