334 replies to this topic

[woolly sheep]

did everyone give up?

[Krizz]

Wow.

WTF

[The Bell Boy]

woolly sheep, on 02 June 2010 - 12:31 PM, said:

did everyone give up?

Pretty much.

[JiB]

i gave up

Edited by JiB, 02 June 2010 - 03:54 PM.

[Achilles]

Let's end it already :(

[JiB]

See, heres the thing.

There are a few things that could of happened that i didnt think could of due to the amount of townies left.

We could of lynched achilles yesterday, rather than lynching MM, because all of yall were innactive. It would have been simple, but no i stuck my foot in there for credibility, and thinking achilles wasnt the cop (because i didnt think hed give you an important role).

Quote

we just lost the game.

i completely underestimated achilles.

That was in response to your one post you made revealing yourself as the cop, you guessed everything 100 percent.

DSS and wolly made themselves pretty obvious (well wolly especially), and Us making the MM inspection was the absolute wrong night to do so.

Edited by JiB, 02 June 2010 - 05:35 PM.

[Ice King]

I only gave away when I voted for Achilles, it was my bad, but I wanted to play it off as a dumb mistake

[Krizz]

I love how Achilles gets the credit when I totally pinned Woolly and DSS right after Drew got killed, haha.

[Ice King]

FYI: I was the corrupt cop and I wanted to confuse the town by revealing townies as townies

And Achilles called me a good mafia player....I lol'd

[woolly sheep]

I knew Achilles was cop long before anyone else. ask the rest of the mafia if you dont believe me.

[drew]

how did you grapeers peg me?

edit: nevermind. Jib was mafia. He always has me pegged, regardless of which side we're on.

Edited by drewsliphay, 02 June 2010 - 10:50 PM.

[JiB]

you made it so obvious drew

i forget what post it was but i was like wow hes obv cop

like, DSS suspected you as cop initially, but as we were deciding who to kill, i double posted w/ "idk who to kill" then "kill drew" so obviously i saw something. I cant remember what it was though.

i believe this was your post:

Quote

I actually have an inkling that this was the case. That msf WAS the mafia cop inspection. Just a hunch...

Edited by JiB, 02 June 2010 - 11:45 PM.

[Mister Mischief]

I pegged Drew for cop when he reacted to Achilles saying cops should drop hints. The day I died sucked, the plan was to either get Achilles lynched, or make sure you guys lynched me so the cop wouldn't know for sure if they were sane or not, that was the best way plan I could come up with when both me and Jib came up as the inspections.

Sucks I wasn't active in the beginning cause I was doing other stuff, and I just happened to be mafia, so then you guys got suspicious. It doesn't help IDC as much about the game when I'm mafia...all I care about is trying to figure out who's who, and being mafia kinda ruins that...

GG Achilles, if I had my way you'd have been dead a lot earlier.

Edited by Mister Mischief, 03 June 2010 - 05:37 AM.

[Ice King]

Yeah, we would have lynched Achilles sooner if he didn't drop the ball on being cop and figured out who to go for next.
By doing so, I figured we had to change it up and choose someone else to kill instead to try to make Achilles look mafia

[Skuff]

hmm oh well
woolly sheep was about to be lynched and he was mafia
the mafia was woolly, jib, mister mischief, and dss (the corrupt cop)
sane cop was drew, insane cop was achilles
this game had a really good turnout i think lol
the town really did a good job utilizing the information flow the inspection plum provided
achilles did a good job as cop, there was discussion in the mafia thread pm about who thought he was cop and who didn't. though we all know that if the mafia wanted to be bananas he could have been killed off first just for his reputation haha
sorry i wasn't on when i should have changed it to night 4 but we made it pretty far anyway, and it was kind of turning out to be a numbers game, especially since achilles came out as cop. which i don't resent, because he actually did it intelligently, unlike how the game went down the first time i did this