827 replies to this topic

[Achilles]

@ Krizz - your power was an alternator. It was false, true, false, true, etc. That's why MM was townie while Xero was mafia.

[Krizz]

Achilles, on 26 July 2010 - 02:48 PM, said:

@ Krizz - your power was an alternator. It was false, true, false, true, etc. That's why MM was townie while Xero was mafia.

Oh. I see. That explains why I didn't see the pattern then. I died too early to notice it.

[Achilles]

By the way guys, how was I as a game host? Did you enjoy the game overall?

[Mister Mischief]

Achilles, on 26 July 2010 - 06:09 PM, said:

By the way guys, how was I as a game host? Did you enjoy the game overall?

My answer to both questions is meh.

Super long days/nights sucked balls, balance of powers between town and mafia were very uneven(assuming everyone plays well), and some powers were just lame. Example of lame powers: Krizz being a cop who's sanity changes randomly, Woolly's "voice".

[BlitzPlayer]

game was good. obv mafia on this forum as a whole is less enjoyable because people like connor, master, wit, etc dont play anymore. i enjoyed it though

[Sage]

Mister Mischief, on 26 July 2010 - 06:18 PM, said:

My answer to both questions is meh.

Super long days/nights sucked balls, balance of powers between town and mafia were very uneven(assuming everyone plays well), and some powers were just lame. Example of lame powers: Krizz being a cop who's sanity changes randomly, Woolly's "voice".

I disagree with this, Voice is a great tool to utilize and it almost worked if it weren't for those meddling kids and their dog. Krizz's sanity didn't change randomly, but I do agree that it's best to have patterned roles like that in a longer game. Twitter's power was like, amazing for the mafia, it easily balanced everything out. I find it odd that you claim that powers were biased towards the town then mention two things that were good for the mafia, especially since the Town's only real detective was the lie detector, who pretty much has to give himself away to do any good because if he doesn't then he can usually only check on things like "I am a [insert role here]" or "I am [insert character here]" or "I [insert power here]'d [insert player here] last night", nothing solid. And our protector had to choose between protecting and using other powers.

It was a good game Achilles, I'd play in another one of yours any time. The length of days/nights could be shortened, but just by a bit because we had just enough time to discuss everything and come up with conclusions/decisions.

[Tenken]

Mafia bombs are meh, but I enjoyed it while I was alive.

I guess Mafia bomb can help analyze who is scared to hammer, but having townies scared to do the right thing is lame. If days ended with time limit alone then I could understand it more, but forcing majority forces someone to go for the possible bomb push to progress the game.

[Mister Mischief]

Sage, on 26 July 2010 - 07:31 PM, said:

I disagree with this, Voice is a great tool to utilize and it almost worked if it weren't for those meddling kids and their dog. Krizz's sanity didn't change randomly, but I do agree that it's best to have patterned roles like that in a longer game. Twitter's power was like, amazing for the mafia, it easily balanced everything out. I find it odd that you claim that powers were biased towards the town then mention two things that were good for the mafia, especially since the Town's only real detective was the lie detector, who pretty much has to give himself away to do any good because if he doesn't then he can usually only check on things like "I am a [insert role here]" or "I am [insert character here]" or "I [insert power here]'d [insert player here] last night", nothing solid. And our protector had to choose between protecting and using other powers.

It was a good game Achilles, I'd play in another one of yours any time. The length of days/nights could be shortened, but just by a bit because we had just enough time to discuss everything and come up with conclusions/decisions.

Since there was a pattern to Krizz' sanity it isn't really that bad at all, I missed Achilles' post explaining that.

The voice is a great tool for townies, but it's pretty lame as a mafia power, it rarely gets townies killed unless they're dumb. Twitter's power is pretty good, if used properly, but other than negation it was our only good tool, and we've seen better version of it in game. Mafia bombs are also really lame.